Surprised by Oxford: A Journey of Faith and Love
Caroline Drake (Rose Reid), an ambitious American student, has always excelled academically. Her dedication and hard work lead her to Oxford University, where she immerses herself in her doctoral dissertation. Within the hallowed halls of the ancient college, she encounters Kent Weber (Rory O’Connor), a charming young man whose religious beliefs differ vastly from her own. Caroline is an atheist, while Kent is a devout Christian committed to celibacy until marriage. Their contrasting worldviews spark numerous debates about faith, literature, and ultimately, an undeniable attraction.
Rose Reid as Caroline in “Surprised by Oxford”
Ryan Whitaker’s film, originally titled “Surprised by Oxford”, is based on Carolyn Weber’s memoir, which chronicles her experiences at Oxford University. While the localized title might suggest a typical romantic drama about clashing opposites, Whitaker’s work delves deeper into Caroline’s spiritual awakening. Although love blossoms within the academic setting, the film primarily focuses on Caroline’s encounter with God. The original title, like the memoir, alludes to C.S. Lewis’s “Surprised by Joy,” a work by the renowned author of “The Chronicles of Narnia.”
Rose Reid as Caroline in “Surprised by Oxford”
From Intellectual Debates to Unexpected Romance
The film cleverly intertwines the search for faith with the romantic storyline. Caroline and Kent’s relationship follows the familiar “enemies to lovers” trope. Initially, Kent’s unwavering beliefs and polite demeanor are off-putting to Caroline, but she eventually finds herself drawn to his unique character. Throughout the film, the two engage in intellectual discussions about literature, philosophy, and, of course, faith. Through these conversations, the rational Caroline attempts to understand Kent, leading her to question her own beliefs about the world and consider the possibility of a higher power.
However, viewers seeking a purely romantic experience may find the development of Caroline and Kent’s relationship somewhat lacking. The conflicts between the characters are often resolved too easily, and the dialogue could benefit from more nuanced writing.
Rose Reid as Caroline in “Surprised by Oxford”
Oxford as a Character
Perhaps the film’s greatest strength lies in its setting. Oxford University itself becomes a character, adding depth and atmosphere to the story. Had “Surprised by Oxford” embraced a darker, more introspective tone, it could have easily fit into the popular dark academia genre, characterized by its university campus setting and mystical undertones. Even without the melancholic atmosphere, the film’s visual elements, including the gothic architecture and dimly lit libraries, are sure to captivate those who appreciate beauty and history.
A Film for Those Seeking Meaning
“Surprised by Oxford” is ultimately a film for those grappling with questions of faith. In addition to exploring theological themes, the film reflects on the tension between reason and intuition, the importance of constructive dialogue and compromise in relationships, and the impact of childhood trauma. While the film may resonate deeply with religious viewers and those interested in the author’s personal story, others may find it difficult to connect with the protagonist’s struggles and may struggle to stay engaged with what is, at its core, a fairly standard melodrama.