The Power of the Dog
Plot
Set in the 1920s, 'The Power of the Dog' is a psychological drama film directed by Jane Campion, adapted from a 1967 New Zealand novella of the same name by Thomas Savage. The story revolves around the complex relationships and tensions within a family of brothers, particularly between the two main male characters: Phil and George Burbank. Phil Burbank, played by Benedict Cumberbatch, is a confident, charismatic, and domineering rancher who lives on his family's Montana ranch. His relationship with his brother, George, played by Jesse Plemons, is one of sibling rivalry and mutual disdain. George marries Rose, a kind-hearted and beautiful schoolteacher, played by Kirsten Dunst, who is pregnant with their first child. Phil is appalled by George's decision to settle down and marry, viewing it as a betrayal of their wild, free-spirited youth. Phil's behavior towards Rose and her 14-year-old son, Peter, becomes increasingly antagonistic and condescending from the moment they arrive on the ranch. He consistently disrespects and belittles Rose, taking pleasure in making her feel inferior and out of place. His actions are motivated by a deep-seated insecurity and jealousy, stemming from his own unresolved feelings of inadequacy and vulnerability. Phil's dominance and control over those around him are merely a facade, hiding the painful reality of his own unmet desires and unrequited love. As Phil's behavior escalates, George becomes increasingly powerless to intervene, caught between his loyalty to his brother and his love for his wife. The tension between Phil and George builds, mirroring their childhood rivalry and struggle for control. Their differences in personality and values serve as a microcosm for the larger conflict between the old and the new, as embodied by Phil's adherence to a bygone era of cowboy lawlessness and George's growing sense of responsibility and domesticity. Rose, a lonely and emotionally exhausted woman, finds herself trapped in a situation she cannot escape. Despite Phil's cruelty and condescension, she becomes increasingly dependent on him, seeking his approval and validation. Her love for George and her desire to create a stable life for herself and her son are constantly threatened by Phil's machinations. As the story unfolds, several long-hidden secrets are slowly revealed. Phil's backstory, including his complicated relationship with his parents, is gradually exposed, shedding light on the root causes of his behavior. George's vulnerabilities and weaknesses are also laid bare, particularly in his desire for a family and a sense of belonging. Meanwhile, Peter, who has been observing Phil's behavior with growing unease, begins to assert himself and stand up to his uncle's bullying. Through their interactions, Peter's complexities and vulnerabilities are revealed, adding depth to the story and foreshadowing a confrontation with Phil. The turning point arrives when Phil's facade is shattered, and his true intentions are revealed. In a series of intense and emotionally charged confrontations, Phil's mask slips, exposing the painful truth about his past and his motivations. Rose, who has been slowly unraveling under Phil's pressure, finally finds the strength to resist his advances, marking a turning point in the story. The film's climax, set against the stunning backdrop of the Montana ranch, is a slow-burning, emotionally charged confrontation between Phil and George. The outcome is far from certain, as the brothers' long-standing tensions come to a head in a violent and unsettling showdown. Ultimately, 'The Power of the Dog' is a nuanced and thought-provoking exploration of masculinity, power dynamics, and the complexities of the human psyche. Beneath its surface-level drama and tension lies a rich, complex tapestry of emotions, desires, and vulnerabilities, deftly woven by director Jane Campion and her cast. The film's performances, cinematography, and direction are all masterful, capturing the essence of a bygone era while speaking to universal themes that continue to resonate today.
Reviews
Peter
He killed him, he was killed by him... terrifying. A bulky younger brother whose purpose remains unseen, a spirited, alcoholic woman, and a fragile boy whose paper flowers are met with ridicule... A brother who toils relentlessly to make money is essentially killed... What a bitter and miserable life. My heart aches numbly.
Mckenzie
The control is terrifying. Beneath the seemingly eternally still hills lies a dog with jaws wide open. Anything that utilizes the iceberg principle to this extent has an immense lingering impact. Reflecting on it, the shift in power doesn't begin when the boy can wield a scalpel, but when he can fold paper flowers. It's a competition between a boy who can fold paper flowers and a man who can burn them – and it's no surprise that the ability to fold paper flowers leads to wielding a scalpel. Stereotypes instantly crumble, and the "anti-hero" deconstructs the traditional Western "hero." Campion is masterful at playing with the dialectic of gender, savagery, and civilization! There’s a "take the son" - "kill the father" - ... arc at play here.
Amira
The most vulnerable are often the sharpest, and the restrained endurance of silent planning can present a bloodless and gentle hunt. Like a taut bowstring, the suspenseful atmosphere is consistently manipulated by Campion's masterful control, rising and falling with tension. A shared cigarette, a subtle wound, the tacit admission into the male world is a subtle trap, a gracious invitation into the snare. The repressed and unspoken homosexual undercurrents of growing up in the Wild West subtly connect the narrative with its rope knot episodes, the shirt fragment, his captive heart, his spoils. The deeper one wades into the past, the more one drowns in it, the higher the walls of malice are built, the louder the barking. The Power of the Dog becomes a mysterious symbol of masculine identity, and in the alternating clashes of masculinity and femininity, in the acts of reference and mimicry, the violent enigma is gradually broken down and resolved.
April
Phil is a closeted gay man who prides himself on his masculinity while denying his true identity. George is an ordinary, "normal" man. Peter is a seemingly effeminate gay man, yet decisive, ruthless, and remarkably calm. Phil, deeply repressed, uses emotional castration and cowardice as his shield, resembling aspects of toxic and fragile masculinity. However, these constructs are ultimately vulnerable, collapsing in the face of genuine strength ("the power of the dog"). This subtly reflects the evolving and enduring definitions of masculinity in society; the film is a sharp reflection of modern times...
Kenneth
I feel a bit melancholic. Perhaps it's because midway through the film, I became preoccupied with the guy in the front row who fell asleep and started snoring, and the other guy next to him, cautiously reaching out a hand, then pulling it back.
Recommendations
